Dear Ofsted,
As a Trust, we now have considerable experience of the new inspection framework, having been through six inspections and two monitoring visits. Because we attend all our inspections, we are in a particularly strong position to comment on how the framework is working in practice, and on the very different experiences it can create from one inspection to another.
Our presence is sometimes seen as a threat by an inspection team and sometimes as evidence of a supportive Trust. For us, it is neither; it is vital to ensuring that school leaders are supported through this “high-stakes, low-trust process”. I will not see our school leaders walk into an inspection without the expertise of our central team to ensure inspectors operate within the framework, advocate for school leaders, support and challenge where necessary, and add capacity during an intense two days. Our last inspection alone required 10.5 senior Trust leader days.
After six inspections and a monitoring visit, I am increasingly concerned about the process’s consistency and the experience of those being inspected. The framework was intended to bring greater consistency to inspections, but our experience is that its application can vary considerably, even between inspections.
Inspection discrepancies
Take governance. We have experienced almost every possible approach: inspectors wanting to see the chair of the board alone; Trust leadership, directors, and school governors meeting together; local governance not being explored at all; and Trust directors not being seen. Inspectors’ expectations are inconsistent: what they expect to see, who they expect to speak to, and how they determine the appropriate level of scrutiny vary widely.
Inspectors also vary widely in how they interpret the extent to which a Trust should be examined as an organisation responsible for a school, and where the boundaries of an individual school inspection should sit. Those boundaries can even shift within the same inspection.
The same is true of the involvement of central Trust staff. Attendance at inspection activities, meetings and reflection sessions has been refused, welcomed or limited, all apparently under the same framework. Inspectors do not always understand the guidance as clearly as our team does!
There is also a striking variation in sharply about how much knowledge a director in a 24-school Trust should have about an individual school. It is simply not realistic to expect the same depth of day-to-day knowledge from a Trust director responsible for multiple schools as you would from a headteacher, but the expectations can sometimes appear to be applied without sufficient recognition of that distinction.
These may sound like relatively small differences, but they point to a much bigger issue. Too often, the experience of an inspection seems to depend on the individual inspector’s interpretation and professional lens, and the small things can expose this most clearly.
We have seen an ambiguous sentence in a policy generate a disproportionate response, while a minor issue in an Early Years provision can suddenly become a significant focus. One centimetre too much water in a tuff tray can become a talking point, just as one ambiguous sentence about school medicine can generate a huge amount of additional work for a Trust team, even if it doesn’t materially change the policy or put children at risk.
Of course, inspectors should notice things and ask questions. The problem is when differences in individual interpretation begin to influence the overall experience and conclusions of an inspection, extending from small operational matters into views about teaching and learning, behaviour, leadership and the use of the IDSR.
Having the inspection Quality Assured
Three of our inspections have been Quality Assured. We understand that the purpose of this process is to assure the quality and consistency of the inspection itself, and that the lead inspector and inspection team are the ones being Quality Assured. In practice, however, our experience is that a Quality Assured inspection changes the dynamic considerably, with the school becoming the collateral damage of a process intended to provide additional assurance.
Quality Assured inspections are ALWAYS harder. The lead inspector becomes less nuanced, less relaxed, and more intense, with apparent second-guessing throughout the inspection and greater hesitancy to share opinions or reach conclusions. We understand that inspections are high stakes for inspectors too, but when the process designed to quality assure an inspection changes the behaviour of the inspection team, the consequence is a less open, less collaborative and more pressured experience for the school which ultimately plays out in the outcomes of the inspection.
In one of our inspections, the School HMI was part of the inspection team on day one and then Quality Assured the inspection on day two. We challenged this at the time and the issue went through the duty desk and beyond, with the position ultimately confirmed by the Ofsted Regional Director – no conflict. Whatever the technical interpretation of the guidance, it raises a reasonable question about whether this arrangement supports confidence in the process’s independence and objectivity.
Context must mean something
The new framework places considerable emphasis on understanding a school’s context, but our experience is that context does not lead the inspection. An inspector may spend the first day demonstrating that they understand the school’s circumstances, but by the second day it’s all about outcomes.
We know that disadvantage, SEND and EHCPs can lead to lower outcomes across the Ofsted board. We, like colleagues, have had inspections where there is a refusal to look at anything beyond the IDSR. You are left wondering why they didn’t just pull up the IDSR make the judgements and save everyone 2 days of ceaseless battle
Unnecessarily adversarial
Perhaps my greatest concern is the emotional and professional toll of the current process. Headteachers, senior leaders and Trust teams are put through two days of intense scrutiny, often in an atmosphere that feels unnecessarily adversarial, and in our case the central team has experienced seven inspections in less than a year.
The irony is that nine times out of ten, the final judgements are the same as the judgements we had reached through our own self-evaluation and shared with inspectors during the initial call. There is nothing wrong with being held to account and there is nothing wrong with challenge, but challenge does not have to mean confrontation, and accountability does not have to mean creating an environment in which experienced educationalists feel that they are fighting for two days simply to be heard.
As a CEO who has attended most of these inspections and sweated through all of them, I have experienced the pressure first-hand. You come out of an inspection having questioned your decisions, your leadership, and, at times, your ability to carry on, and I am not at all surprised that some heads are refusing to go through another one and are taking early retirement or career changes – imagine going through seven!
If that is happening at scale, we should all be concerned about what it means for the future of education. The profession cannot afford to lose experienced school leaders because the process intended to assure the quality of education has become something they feel unable or unwilling to face again.
Accountability matters
I want to be absolutely clear that I do not know anyone in education who is arguing that schools and Trusts should not be held to account. Our work changes children’s lives, and as a society, we have a responsibility to ensure every child and young person has the opportunity to flourish and succeed. We also spend significant amounts of public money, and the public has every right to know that it is being used well.
What I am saying is that there are better ways.
My Director of Finance goes through both an internal and an external audit every year. She is challenged, scrutinised and held to account, and the process is rigorous enough to identify weaknesses and drive improvement. Yet not once has she, or I, been reduced to tears by an auditor, and there must be a lesson in that.
I welcome the Secretary of State’s call to look again at the current inspection framework, and I hope this creates an opportunity for genuine reflection at Ofsted. This should be about more than refining the wording of a framework; it should be an honest examination of how the framework is interpreted and experienced by the people who work in our schools and Trusts.
Ofsted has an important role to play, as does the education sector. We need a system that provides meaningful accountability, identifies where children are not receiving the education they deserve and drives improvement where it is needed, but we also need a system that recognises the professionalism of those working in our schools and Trusts, uses context intelligently and applies its framework consistently. Above all, accountability must be fair, proportionate and focused on what matters most: the experience, education and outcomes of children and young people.
Perhaps it is also time for all of us in education to find our collective voice. For too long, heads, governors and Trust leaders have been reluctant to put their heads above the parapet, worried that challenging the system might somehow affect the next inspection. We should not be in a position where a favourable judgement leaves us feeling grateful that we have somehow survived the process, rather than confident that we have been through a fair and professional assessment of our work.
So I would urge headteachers, governors, Trusts and those who care about education to come together and speak honestly about what is working and what is not. We should be able to challenge the system without fear, share our experiences without worrying about consequences, and demand an inspection process that is rigorous without being unnecessarily adversarial.
We all want accountability. We all want to know that children are safe, learning, and being given the opportunities they deserve. The question is not whether we should be held to account, but how we do it. It is time to build a system that is rigorous, consistent, fair and proportionate, and that keeps children firmly at its heart.
I am hoping that Ofsted will use this moment to listen, reflect, and change. But perhaps the bigger question is whether we, as a profession, are prepared to speak together and ask for the system our children, our schools and our staff deserve.
Jackie Waters-Dewhurst
CEO | LAAT